Cognitive Models: Mechanistic and Dynamical Approaches with Paul Kelly
This episode delves into the philosophical and practical distinctions between mechanistic and dynamical models, highlighting their significance in cognitive science and climate science. Paul and Andrea also unpack the 3M principle, surrogative reasoning, and equilibrium models, emphasizing the role of models in scientific inquiry and their broader implications for understanding complex systems. Perfect for enthusiasts of cognitive science, philosophy, and anyone fascinated by the dynamic intersection of these fields.
#model #cognition #love #philosophy
Watch is in video on the Love and Philosophy You Tube Research Channel.
Find more about Paul and his work at: https://pauljkelly.weebly.com/
00:00 Introduction and Disclaimers
00:43 Introducing Paul Kelly and the Topic of Cognition
01:41 Diving into Modelling Cognition
02:39 Philosophical Foundations and Definitions
07:06 Paul Kelly's Journey into Philosophy and Science
28:43 Mechanistic Models Explained
45:42 Debate on Mechanistic vs. Dynamical Models
46:49 Philosophical Assumptions in Mechanistic Models
47:43 Mechanistic Models in Neuroscience
50:02 Three Kinds of Mechanism
51:44 Mechanistic vs. Dynamical Systems Theory
01:03:20 Constitutive vs. Causal Explanation
01:06:33 The 3M Principle
01:23:37 Explanatory Power of Dynamical Models
01:29:49 Understanding AI and Neural Networks
01:30:31 Dynamical Systems Theory in AI
01:32:43 Mechanistic vs. Dynamical Models
01:34:26 Equilibrium Models in Science
01:38:01 Evaluating Models: Adequacy for Purpose
01:45:57 Model Integration and Transfer
01:50:32 Philosophical Implications of Models
02:00:17 The Role of Models in Practical Applications
02:01:39 Surrogates vs. Models
02:05:32 Language and Representation
02:09:04 Final Thoughts and Future Directions
For those who want to delve deeper, join Way & Lifeworld.
About this podcast:
Beyond Dichotomy started as research conversations & has expanded beyond my own academic pursuits towards noticing the patterns that connect across traditional divides.
When I started my studies, there was so much I wanted to explore that I was told I shouldn't explore because it didn't fit into this or that discipline, but having studied and worked in so many fields, those barriers no longer made sense. The same felt true relative to passions and love.
So I decided to open myself to all of it beyond traditional distinctions, towards learning and development. This podcast is where those voices gather together in one space as I try and notice the patterns that connect.
It's part of my life work and research, but it's also something I hope to share with you and to invite you to share your perspective and position. Thank you for being here.
Note: These conversations take place approximate 5 to 8 weeks before they post
Can we model cognition?