4 Comments
User's avatar
Kevin Ionno's avatar

I am a fan of William James. If he were alive today, this seems like where he would be. I like the idea of values being tools; ethics in different permutations as tools to shape perspective and action with the aim of contributing to the flourishing of life. I like that this is all described as constant movement. Therefore, truth can be changing and yet always be true. In fact, it seems that in some ways you are talking about systems without using the term. Systems change through responsive experimentation. Every action is a response which both solves a problem and asks a new question. This all fits into your definition of pluralism, I think. Monism is sticky because while everything seems to be always in flux, there is a sense, to paraphrase Kuhn, of what it is like to exist. Apparently there is nothing outside of existence, and so perhaps existence itself is the Monad.

I’m just thinking out loud. Thanks for listening, and for your excellent conversation.

Love and Philosophy's avatar

Thank you for this thinking out loud! Please do this any time as we have much enjoyed it. Big fans here too of William James and this also connects to the more pragmatist shift that will be discussed more in further conversations about this work. Especially pleased to read that you liked the movement and active oriented ways of considering knowledge.

Kevin Ionno's avatar

BTW, as I think of it, the eternal verities of the platonic realm have always served as tools for humans to use to shape their world. Think of the good, the beautiful, and the true. The task of creators has always been to find the better good, the more beautiful, and the more true in all fields of human endeavor, including science. William James meets Plato.

Andrea Hiott's avatar

yes, this ‘the good, the beautiful and the true’ bothers me a bit lately though because it assumes a sort of perfection that i am not sure is as motivating…i am beginning to focus on the conversational aspect of Plato and others as the real place we find the motivation towards being better, seeing more beauty in more of what we encounter, and being more truthful…this sort of framing is what i’ve been feeling into lately at least…not this ‘goal’ that is always unreachable in some way but this ongong conversational potentiation