16 Comments
User's avatar
Debbie Aliya's avatar

Will there be a video?

Andrea Hiott's avatar

Hope you found it Debbie, and hope you are well.

Love and Philosophy's avatar

Yes. It is now available in the paid area here and also in the YT members section and it will go live for everyone in a couple weeks.

Whit Blauvelt's avatar

"Unconscious memories aren’t recalled as images; they’re repeated as 'motor policies.'"

In The Ego and the Id (at least in the Strachey translation) Freud clearly writes that the unconscious contents come to consciouisness by association with "word presentations." Freud was also big in his early works on supposedly recovered memories of childhood sexual abuse, as detailed by Frederick Crews in his New York Review of Books articles and elsewhere. I look forward to listening to Solms here. But excuse me for going in with some skepticism (although I think the "word presentations" claim has some deeply interesting implications -- in a direction apparently Solms doesn't go).

Andrea Hiott's avatar

Fully welcome the skepticism and look forward to hearing what you think of all this Whit

Randy Gazda's avatar

Yes, the subjective experience and objective mechanism are two views of the same underlying process. That’s close to how I think about identity: a pattern that maintains itself from the inside as a story of itself and the outside as a cog in a larger purpose. The rest of the discussion about memory systems and transference fits into that same continuity model.

Andrea Hiott's avatar

Thank you, wonderfully written. Would also love to hear more about how you’re using ‘continuity model’ here.

Randy Gazda's avatar

I use “continuity model” to describe how a system preserves a stable pattern across changes in state. From the inside, that looks like identity: the system experiences itself as the same agent over time. From the outside, it looks like coherence: the boundary keeps reorganizing just enough to maintain the pattern. Mutual incorporation fits into this because two systems temporarily share a single continuity loop. Each adjusts its boundary to sustain the joint pattern long enough for meaning to emerge.

Andrea Hiott's avatar

Indeed. I suppose I would add that there is no ‘one’ inside or outside to this process, even when considering the same agent, so we also would do well to always consider context (landscape) and aim. Does that make sense with your model and ideas as well?

Randy Gazda's avatar

Yes, context and aim fit naturally into the continuity model. The pattern's “inside” and “outside” are always shaped by the landscape it’s acting within and the direction it’s trying to move. Any "one" agent is really a continuity loop adjusting across conditions, so the boundary is a position the pattern can hold under changing pressure.

Debbie Aliya's avatar

Could you please post or DM the link?

Thank you.

Love and Philosophy's avatar

Can’t post links here apparently but it’s on the main page and also on youtube, we DM’d you both

Debbie Aliya's avatar

Thank you. I listened to the first hour on the way in to work.

I found it very interesting. Just got a volume booster on my phone so I can now listen while driving in my subjectively noisy experience creating 2010 Toyota Yaris with 334K miles, even with my aging former electric furnace steel mill damaged hearing. :>)

Mark Solms has indeed done us a service to recover Freud's work. I never understood why people wrote Freud off. Clearly he did not have the whole picture. Why would any one person. But clearly he laid even more groundwork than most of us were aware of.

As a materials engineer, we are taught that the foundation of the field is understanding the structure of the material (at the level of how atoms of different species are grouped), and that we can influence that structure by how we process the material (cast, forged, thermally treated, etc.) Then the structure of material influences the behavior of the material.

Your conversation with Mark showed how Freud started with the structure of the neuronal cells. Went on to understand that how we live our lives influences how those cells operate to generate our responses to life and create a feedback loop to influence our lives.

Process (Life Experience) => Structure => Behavior

In the case of the brain / mind, behavior influenced, as he explained so well on your podcast, and in his older book, The Hidden Spring, by AFFECT. By FEELINGS.

I am still confused about his statement in The Hidden Spring regarding his support for / belief in / knowledge of “substrate independence.” Silicon is not bathed in hormones. So I am, as I said, confused. Maybe he renounced substrate independence elsewhere.

As for the talking cure, yes. I have struggled with depression most of my life. There were years, if not decades, that my first thought in the morning was “F***, I’m still alive.” That is gone now. I still have despair about the world, but cultivating clarity of thought, and cultivating creative ways of seeing, have both created a better course for my life. My ex used to tell me I should medicate myself, but I don’t like doctors very much, and was concerned about side effects.

I will probably write more after I finish listening.

Andrea Hiott's avatar

I feel lots of resonance with this Debbie and really thank you for sharing it. At some point I also hope to share more relative to these points when I’m able but for now just wanted to say thank you and also congrats/v cool to hear about the volume booster! :)

Debbie Aliya's avatar

Ok. I listened to more. Need to go back now as I got distracted. But I had to make note of Mark's comments at 1:20 (ish) about "Free Won't." That we don't have free will, but we can have "Free Won't." We can learn to say no to the automatic responses that our subconscious minds serve up without scrutiny. Because these invisible unconscious responses are "hard to learn and hard to unlearn."

I would simply say that despite everyone "proving scientifically" that there's no free will because of the neural impulses that happen before we move our hand, etc. is NOT POSSIBLE. Because "free will" is a construct. It is not a concrete object that can have "yes" or "no" "True" or "False" statements made about it. Doing is is falling into the trap of the Reification Error.

I look at Free Will as the useful construct it is. As Niels Bohr says (more or less) "The opposite of a GREAT TRUTH is another great truth."

As the great George Gurdjieff is said to have said (but I can't find the quote, so it's among my favorite "non-quotes") "We have free will, but we have one foot nailed to the ground."

If, as Mark said, based on Freud, we have "Free Won't," we can start to build Free Will in some areas of our lives, despite the layers and layers of genetic and cultural programming we have. In my case, I still find myself lacking as much will as I would like. That forces me to build my depth of compassion. That too helps me acquire new skills where it matters, social capital.

Love and Philosophy's avatar

Thanks for reminding of the ‘free won’t’ part! Need to listen to that again too and perhaps highlight this. Would also like to do something going into more depth about free will and the famous Libet Experiment which does not hold at all in a movement and oriented understanding of mind and knowledge.